Afghanistan has been called the graveyard of empires, a fitting (though not technically accurate) name considering the fiasco we are now witnessing as the US withdraws from the country after a 20-year occupation that was doomed from the start.
"During the history of Afghanistan, several superpowers had attempted to invade Afghanistan without maintaining a stable, permanent rule. Modern examples included the British Empire during the Third Anglo-Afghan War (1919), the Soviet Union in the Soviet–Afghan War (1979 – 1989) and the United States in the War in Afghanistan (2001 – 2021). Some had attributed ancient empires to the narrative, including the Persians, Greeks, Arabs, Turks and Mongols. The difficulty in invading Afghanistan was attributed to the prevalence of fortress-like qalats, the deserts, the mountainous terrain of Afghanistan, its severe winter and its "impregnable clan loyalties." (Wikipedia)
Alexander the Great is frequently included in the list of foreign invaders who failed to subdue Afghanistan, but this isn't really accurate since the Greeks under various leaders managed to hold on to their territory in Afghanistan for centuries.
To sum it up briefly, Alexander invaded what is now Afghanistan in 329-330 BC during his wider war against the Persian Empire. He fought hard battles against local tribes, renamed his territory Bactria, and settled some of his veterans in cities which he founded there. Then he moved on to invade the Indus River Basin in what is now India. Faced with a mutiny by his troops -- which he managed to contain -- he was forced to return to his base in Babylon where he died from unknown causes, possibly murdered.
"Following the death of Alexander and the partition of his kingdom, the Province of Bactria was under the rule of Alexander's former general, Seleucus, who now formed the Seleucid Dynasty, with its capital in Babylon. But the Greek soldiers in Bactria, based on the remoteness of their territory, declared independence, defeated Seleucid armies sent to reconquer them, and founded the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom, which lasted for more than three centuries in Afghanistan, and western India." (Wikipedia)
These Greco-Bactrians "left a legacy of coinage, architecture, and Buddhist art, which comprised the Ghandara culture, especially the Greco-Buddhist Art affecting all of East Asia to this day. The last Greek Kingdom in Afghanistan was conquered by the Kushan invaders in the first century AD, a full three centuries after Alexander. But Greek language continued to be used by the Kushans in their coinage for the next several centuries."
The claim that Alexander failed to conquer Afghanistan isn't historically accurate. He did conquer the country -- part of it, anyway -- and the Greeks occupied the region for centuries until they were finally conquered by another invading force. The Kushans defeated the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom and went on to occupy most of Afghanistan for a couple more centuries until they, in turn, were defeated by yet another outside invasion:
"The Kushan Empire fragmented into semi-independent kingdoms in the 3rd century AD, which fell to the Sasanians invading from the west, establishing the Kushano-Sasanian Kingdom in the areas of Sogdiana, Bactria and Gandhara. In the 4th century, the Guptas, an Indian dynasty also pressed from the east. The last of the Kushan and Kushano-Sasanian kingdoms were eventually overwhelmed by invaders from the north, known as the Kidarites, and then the Hephthalites." (Wikipedia)
And on and on it has gone in Afghanistan, a tumultuous history of conquest and re-conquest which has led up to the predictable disaster we are watching unfold right now. Afghanistan may not be the graveyard of the American Empire, but this really mind-boggling failure will definitely be a major milestone in the continuing decline of the United States.
Report from August 15, 2021. Also see Afghanistan, Lost (NBC, same day). By the time this post appears, the Taliban may be in control of the entire country.
The legacy of "coinage, architecture, and Buddhist art" left behind by Alexander and the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom still survives in the British Museum and other museums. Some have condemned these collections for being a "theft of cultural heritage" and so on, but these priceless artifacts will be far safer in Britain and elsewhere than they would be in Afghanistan, which will soon -- very soon -- fall under the total control of the same Taliban fanatics who destroyed the Buddhas of Bamiyan back in 2001. An attempt was launched to reconstruct the Buddha statues after the Taliban was driven out, but now that they're back in power I'm sure that work will be discontinued immediately.
Notes: "The Battle of Issus (5th November, 333 BCE) was Alexander the Great's second battle against the Persian army and the first direct engagement with King Darius III, near the village of Issus in southern modern-day Turkey. It was a major victory for Alexander, defeating the Persian army and causing Darius III to flee the battlefield." Source: Ancient History Encyclopedia.
First stage of the battle: The two armies faced each other on opposite banks of the what is thought to have been the Pinaros River. "As Alexander moved towards the River Pinaros he thinned out his center to extend his line on both wings. By the time battle was joined his forces outflanked those of Darius despite being fewer in number. The battle commenced with both sides charging across the river, in opposite directions, with their right-wing units." Source: The Landmark Arrian -- The Campaigns of Alexander (p.74), edited by James Romm.
Second stage of the battle: "With his extended right wing, Alexander was able to get around and behind Darius' front-line infantry once the Persian left had been routed. The approach of Alexander's cavalry caused Darius to flee, according to Arrian, and the Persian right, which had been prevailing up to that point over Parmenion and Krateros, soon followed his retreat." (Ibid, p.75)
Comment: Alexander was a master of flanking movements and he had inherited a highly-skilled army from his father, the underrated Philip II of Macedon. As for Darius III, I wouldn't want to call him an effete coward, so I'll just say that he had a tendency to run the minute he thought his own life was in danger, abandoning his soldiers to their fate. A stronger leader might have been able to salvage the situation at Issus since his right wing was still doing well, but Darius was no Alexander the Great.
The diagram below (from Wikipedia) shows the situation at the critical moment of the battle. Alexander's forces are in blue, the Persians in red. Note that the Persian right wing had forced Alexander's left to retreat. If the battle had continued, it looks like it would have revolved like a wheel in a counter-clockwise motion and the Persian forces might have been able to defeat the Macedonians then and there.
"On 9 March 2017, Egyptian and German archaeologists discovered a colossal statue about 7.9 metres (26 ft) in height at the Heliopolis site in Cairo. Made of quartzite, the statue was found in a fragmentary state, with the bust, the lower part of the head and the crown submerged in groundwater." Source: Wikipedia.
"It has been confirmed to be of Psamtik I due to engravings found that mentioned one of the pharaoh's names on the base of the statue."
Archaeologists were apparently attempting to rebuild or at least partially rebuild this huge statue back in 2019, but I'm not sure how much progress has been made on the project. Psamtik I (ruled 664 - 610 BC) founded the 26th Dynasty, aka the Saite Period, the last native Egyptian dynasty before the Persian Conquest of 525 BC turned Egypt into a satrapy of the Achaemenid Persian Empire. This was the beginning of an extremely turbulent period in Egyptian history.
The brutality of Persian rule goes a long way towards explaining why the Egyptians submitted to Alexander without a fight. He was seen, rightly so, as a liberator, but the days of Egyptian independence were long over.
"Various authorities, both ancient and modern (starting with Herodotus) have sought links with Egypt to explain the origins of certain medical practices, especially surgery in the Greek world. Others have found links with the near east, and with Babylonian medicine in particular, although these have proved very difficult to prove. Some argue that the Hellenistic doctors working in Alexandria continued to be influenced by Egyptian traditional medicine in the 4th and 3rd cents. BC. In the 5th cent. BC, when Herodotus told the story of Darius' Greek physician, Democedes of Croton, the really surprising feature of his career -- apart from its conspicuous success -- was Democedes' technical superiority over the Egyptian doctors." Source: Oxford Classical Dictionary (3rd ed. revised).
According to the Ancient History Encyclopedia (1), "the Egyptian Imhotep (2667 - 2648 BCE) is the first physician in history known by name. The earliest known surgery in Egypt was performed in Egypt around 2750 BCE. TheKahun Gynaecological Papyrus treats women's complaints, including problems with conception. Thirty four cases detailing diagnosis and treatment survive, some of them fragmentarily. Dating to 1800 BCE, it is the oldest surviving medical text of any kind. Medical institutions, referred to as Houses of Life are known to have been established in ancient Egypt as early as the 1st Dynasty."
(1) This quote is taken from an article which no longer exists. The Ancient History Encyclopedia apparently reorganized their entries for ancient medicine, dividing the subject into various categories which can be found here.
"The site, called Qalatga Darband, was directly on the route that Alexander the Great took as he pursued the Persian ruler Darius III in 331 B.C. before their epic battle at Gaugamela. The site bears signs of Greco-Roman influence, including wine presses and smashed statues that may have once depicted the gods Persephone and Adonis."
According to the British Museum, "The site of Qalatga Darband initially came to the attention of archaeologists following the identification of apparently ancient remains in declassified [in 1995] imagery from the 1960s Corona spy satellite programme. Of particular interest is a large square building which may have been a fort. A ground inspection at the site revealed the presence of a large number of carved limestone blocks, together with weights and bases of a type associated with wine or oil presses. It was therefore clear that remains of considerable importance lay buried at the site."
Note: Working on information from the old Corona program, "researchers used drone technology to confirm that the site is indeed home to a previously unexplored fortified settlement." (Smithsonian Magazine)
"It is one of the greatest archaeological mysteries of all times: the disappearance of a Persian army of 50,000 men in the Egyptian desert around 524 BC. Leiden University Professor Olaf Kaper unearthed a cover-up affair and solved the riddle." Source: Science Daily (2014).
"The ships, named 'triremes' for their three rows of oars, are long gone. But underwater archaeologists who spent more than a decade excavating the site where they once rested found remnants of the so-called 'ship sheds' that protected the boats, part of an enormous and fortified naval stronghold beneath what is now the Mounichia fishing and yachting harbor."
Note: "In 480, the Persian king Xerxes invaded Greece. After victories at Thermopylae and Artemisium and a minor setback in the straits of Salamis, it seemed as if he would return to Greece to finish the job in the summer of 479. However, the Persian commander in Europe, Mardonius, had insufficient troops to overcome the Greek army that united at the Cithaeron mountain range and was commanded by Pausanias." Source: Livius.org
"On the plain north of Plataea, the decisive battle took place, and the Persians were defeated."
Note: "According to Herodotus, the Persians fielded 350,000 troops against the Greek forces of 108,200. The figures for the Persians may have been exaggerated in order to make the Persians into a more formidable opponent, and perhaps in reality they fielded a very similar number of combatants to the Greeks. However, even with a more conservative estimate, the battle involved some 200,000 armed men, the largest such battle Greece had seen and a figure comparable with the battles of Waterloo and Gettysburg." Source: Ancient History Encyclopedia.
"The Norwegian Vikings maintained trade connections with Persia and the Byzantine Empire. A network of traders from a variety of places and cultures brought the silk to the Nordic countries." Source: Science Daily (2013)
The Legacy Of Alexander The Great In Afghanistan
Video from 2011.
Afghanistan has been called the graveyard of empires, a fitting (though not technically accurate) name considering the fiasco we are now witnessing as the US withdraws from the country after a 20-year occupation that was doomed from the start.
"During the history of Afghanistan, several superpowers had attempted to invade Afghanistan without maintaining a stable, permanent rule. Modern examples included the British Empire during the Third Anglo-Afghan War (1919), the Soviet Union in the Soviet–Afghan War (1979 – 1989) and the United States in the War in Afghanistan (2001 – 2021). Some had attributed ancient empires to the narrative, including the Persians, Greeks, Arabs, Turks and Mongols. The difficulty in invading Afghanistan was attributed to the prevalence of fortress-like qalats, the deserts, the mountainous terrain of Afghanistan, its severe winter and its "impregnable clan loyalties." (Wikipedia)
Alexander the Great is frequently included in the list of foreign invaders who failed to subdue Afghanistan, but this isn't really accurate since the Greeks under various leaders managed to hold on to their territory in Afghanistan for centuries.
To sum it up briefly, Alexander invaded what is now Afghanistan in 329-330 BC during his wider war against the Persian Empire. He fought hard battles against local tribes, renamed his territory Bactria, and settled some of his veterans in cities which he founded there. Then he moved on to invade the Indus River Basin in what is now India. Faced with a mutiny by his troops -- which he managed to contain -- he was forced to return to his base in Babylon where he died from unknown causes, possibly murdered.
"Following the death of Alexander and the partition of his kingdom, the Province of Bactria was under the rule of Alexander's former general, Seleucus, who now formed the Seleucid Dynasty, with its capital in Babylon. But the Greek soldiers in Bactria, based on the remoteness of their territory, declared independence, defeated Seleucid armies sent to reconquer them, and founded the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom, which lasted for more than three centuries in Afghanistan, and western India." (Wikipedia)
These Greco-Bactrians "left a legacy of coinage, architecture, and Buddhist art, which comprised the Ghandara culture, especially the Greco-Buddhist Art affecting all of East Asia to this day. The last Greek Kingdom in Afghanistan was conquered by the Kushan invaders in the first century AD, a full three centuries after Alexander. But Greek language continued to be used by the Kushans in their coinage for the next several centuries."
The claim that Alexander failed to conquer Afghanistan isn't historically accurate. He did conquer the country -- part of it, anyway -- and the Greeks occupied the region for centuries until they were finally conquered by another invading force. The Kushans defeated the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom and went on to occupy most of Afghanistan for a couple more centuries until they, in turn, were defeated by yet another outside invasion:
"The Kushan Empire fragmented into semi-independent kingdoms in the 3rd century AD, which fell to the Sasanians invading from the west, establishing the Kushano-Sasanian Kingdom in the areas of Sogdiana, Bactria and Gandhara. In the 4th century, the Guptas, an Indian dynasty also pressed from the east. The last of the Kushan and Kushano-Sasanian kingdoms were eventually overwhelmed by invaders from the north, known as the Kidarites, and then the Hephthalites." (Wikipedia)
And on and on it has gone in Afghanistan, a tumultuous history of conquest and re-conquest which has led up to the predictable disaster we are watching unfold right now. Afghanistan may not be the graveyard of the American Empire, but this really mind-boggling failure will definitely be a major milestone in the continuing decline of the United States.
Report from August 15, 2021. Also see Afghanistan, Lost (NBC, same day). By the time this post appears, the Taliban may be in control of the entire country.
The legacy of "coinage, architecture, and Buddhist art" left behind by Alexander and the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom still survives in the British Museum and other museums. Some have condemned these collections for being a "theft of cultural heritage" and so on, but these priceless artifacts will be far safer in Britain and elsewhere than they would be in Afghanistan, which will soon -- very soon -- fall under the total control of the same Taliban fanatics who destroyed the Buddhas of Bamiyan back in 2001. An attempt was launched to reconstruct the Buddha statues after the Taliban was driven out, but now that they're back in power I'm sure that work will be discontinued immediately.
Posted at 07:00 AM in Alexander, Ancient Asia, Ancient Warfare, Architecture, Art, Collapse, Commentary, Culture, Current Affairs, Greece, Persians, Videos, Warfare | Permalink